Do you forgive Mills for sticking his finger up at the crowd

[Archie's penalty]

Simple question, requires a simple answer.

Me, no.

[tomrfcurz]

Yes. You wouldnt even be asking the question if he was still here. Muppet thing to do but gone and (was) forgotten. Until his move...

[Archie's penalty]

Yes. You wouldnt even be asking the question if he was still here. Muppet thing to do but gone and (was) forgotten. Until his move...

Good answer. Still to look at some of the ire about him leaving it seems a lot still haven't forgiven him.

Anyway Leicester's going to be great grudge match.

[Ian Royal]

One moment of stupidity, for which he apologised, so yes forgiven. The problem is it was just the most obvious of a fair few things he could be criticised for so it's been resurrected now he's left.

[who are ya?]

Yes. He stuck his middle finger up in the air after getting shit from the crowd, he didn't murder a family member..

[Ups and Downs]

Knowing what mongs Reading fans can be, yes.

We wont replace him with anywhere near the same quality.

[KEBEISTHEGREATEST]

Next season when he comes to the Mad Stand with the Foxes.

Thats all do: Thats all do it like Matty Mills. Then put our fingers up at him?

[URZZ]

Genuine curiosity: Can I ask why he did it in the first place? I didn't go to the game.

[KEBEISTHEGREATEST]

He was lobbing the ball up field continiously going nowhere. Fans got on his back became pissed. Turned to the stand and then put his fingers up. Stormed off after the game.

[who are ya?]

Next season when he comes to the Mad Stand with the Foxes.

Thats all do: Thats all do it like Matty Mills. Then put our fingers up at him?

Are you drunk

[manny96]

Yes but I think it still influenced the way I saw him (that and the ill-discipline etc.). Holding it against him could have affected how he and the team played, therefore had to forgive it after the apology. Now, couldn't care less how he performs as long as he bottles it against us. It was a ridiculous overeaction in the first place to what was really innocuous groaning from the East stand.

[KEBEISTHEGREATEST]

15 Year Old Drunk. I will consider it.
It would be a laugh like when Chelsea came to Reading in 2006/2007. Thats all do it like Chelsea. Diving action.

[SCIAG]

Yes, I forgive him for the finger as he apologised and it was fairly understandable.

I don't forgive him for his discipline, his attitude towards referees and his attitude towards team mates.

[Colin Cheeselog]

Fans got on his back became pissed. Turned to the stand and then put his fingers up. Stormed off after the game.

Well that's a reasonable explination. I hadn't realised he was pissed at the time.

[bigmike]

He acted in a totally unprofessional manner and the petulant way he stomped off the pitch at the end sums him up.. No Class

Hes just immature and to be fair he will not grow up untill he retires and becomes a member of the real world

[Schards#2]

Yes, immature and unprofessional but one of the funnier moments of recent seasons.

[Forbury Lion]

Nothing to forgive.

[Terminal Boardom]

Who?

[Royal Lady]

15 Year Old Drunk. I will consider it.
It would be a laugh like when Chelsea came to Reading in 2006/2007. Thats all do it like Chelsea. Diving action.

Is English your first language - only in both your recent posts you appear to think the chant is "Thats all do a Millsy" or "Thats all do it like Chelsea" - the word you are looking for is Let's. I do HTH.

[Hoop Blah]

A mix of this

Yes, I forgive him for the finger as he apologised and it was fairly understandable.

I don't forgive him for his discipline, his attitude towards referees and his attitude towards team mates.

and this

He acted in a totally unprofessional manner and the petulant way he stomped off the pitch at the end sums him up.. No Class

Hes just immature and to be fair he will not grow up untill he retires and becomes a member of the real world

I couldn't really care less about the finger incident itself. I openly admit to having serious doubts about his character and the amount that will hold him back in the future though (as it did at Reading) and this little paddy fit from him just highlights his weaknesses.