The Rouge Here is my verdict on how they played in league games so far (McCleary's cameo in game 1 I have included)
McAnuff
Poor - Stoke (H)
Fantastic - Chelsea (A)
Poor - Spurs (H)
OK - WBA (A)
McCleary
V Good - Stoke (H)
OK - Chelsea (A)
Good - Spurs (H)
Fairly Poor - WBA (A)
It is not as simple as that though. McCleary's movement could have been netter against WBA but we were painfully slow in getting the ball out to him. I am actually a big fan of HRK, I think his technique, skill, power and aerial ability makes him a real player with an impact. I personally would go with HRK and Kebe/McCleary for the next game.
I also rate HRK - I thought he did great in the second half against QPR using his power to get round the back and actually put in some pretty decent crosses. I'd play him and potentially look to move McAnuff inside - though whose place he'd take is too hard to call for me.