by Snowball » 20 Mar 2020 08:02
by Zip » 20 Mar 2020 08:18
Dr_HfuhruhurrZip So Italy is suffering a death rate double the rest of the world it seems. Is there a specific reason for that? Is it due to more elderly being infected? Is there an age breakdown for those affected?
To answer your second question - the age breakdown is overwhelmingly old patients in Italy.
It has been surmised that the following is contributing to the high death rate in Italy
1. The number of old people in Italy
2. The recording of death to coronavirus is very generous and in Italy essentially means "death with coronavirus"
3. Lombardy has a high(er) rate of comorbidity with lung disease
4. Italy has a ventilator shortage and cannot ventilate everybody.
The concept that this the Italy results are suprising because Italy has one of the best NHS's in Europe has essentially been debunked because a) the statistics are out of date and show that Italy USED to have one of the best NHS;s. b) The measure of NHS worthiness is not especially weighted towards indicators that it is making people better. There are a lot of different factors that contribute to that score
As to whether their lockdown is working or not is a highly charged debate. I think there are merits to both sides of the debate here. Lockdown doesnt have an endgame and will destroy your economy. There is a short term gain with long term problems. Not locking down will increase the spread of the virus. There are short term problems, but will be better in the long term. The preppers need the curfew breakers to keep the economy going, and to provide some level of immunity to future outbreaks. The curfew breakers need the preppers to keep the current situation manageable. TBH, I dont particularly criticise either the preppers or the curfew breakers - I think we need a balance. The UK approach may appear outwardly shambolic (thats because it is!) but it may prove to be one of the better models.
by Royalwaster » 20 Mar 2020 11:15
by Hound » 20 Mar 2020 12:52
Dr_Hfuhruhurr As to whether their lockdown is working or not is a highly charged debate. I think there are merits to both sides of the debate here. Lockdown doesnt have an endgame and will destroy your economy. There is a short term gain with long term problems. Not locking down will increase the spread of the virus. There are short term problems, but will be better in the long term. The preppers need the curfew breakers to keep the economy going, and to provide some level of immunity to future outbreaks. The curfew breakers need the preppers to keep the current situation manageable. TBH, I dont particularly criticise either the preppers or the curfew breakers - I think we need a balance. The UK approach may appear outwardly shambolic (thats because it is!) but it may prove to be one of the better models.
by Sutekh » 20 Mar 2020 13:17
by Royalwaster » 20 Mar 2020 14:20
by Cape Town Royal » 20 Mar 2020 14:30
by Snowball » 20 Mar 2020 18:46
by Zip » 20 Mar 2020 22:31
Cape Town Royal Its been interesting reading all your comments and how things are in the UK. I'm in Japan and so far the confirmed numbers have remained fairly stable which is surprising given the number of Chinese tourists that came here up until it all went bang.. However for the 900 or so cases we have here the death rate is about 3.5% which given the quality of the health system here seems high especially when compared to South Korea's low percentage. Maybe its because we have a high percentage of old people and the testing has been lower?
Today they have told us to avoid using public transport in the Osaka area which seems strange given we only have 900+ confirmed cases of which about 200 have been finalised. But seriously if you walk about you would never believe there was a pandemic in full flow... Yesterday I was in Kobe city, people walking about in the city as normal (it is almost impossible to stop Japanese women going shopping), but some shops were closing (it seems voluntary) and today in my area I went to the supermarket and the kids (schools are closed) are all out playing football / volleyball / baseball in the parks whilst the mums are all sat en-masse on mats around the edge having picnic parties..
A few days ago they repeated the aim to hold the Olympics in July? Really? We have tickets but just cannot see how they can start to even consider holding it in July given the numbers globally are climbing the walls at an almost vertical rate and its only 4 months away... Who's going to come (you can't get into Japan as of yesterday from most countries) and how can athletes get ready..
Seriously, if you were not aware of the pandemic and came to Japan the way people are going about their daily lives you would never know we were in the middle of a global pandemic...
I am not sure where else in the world we have Reading fans but would be interesting to read how fans in other countries are being affected by this...
by Jagermesiter1871 » 21 Mar 2020 00:01
ZipCape Town Royal Its been interesting reading all your comments and how things are in the UK. I'm in Japan and so far the confirmed numbers have remained fairly stable which is surprising given the number of Chinese tourists that came here up until it all went bang.. However for the 900 or so cases we have here the death rate is about 3.5% which given the quality of the health system here seems high especially when compared to South Korea's low percentage. Maybe its because we have a high percentage of old people and the testing has been lower?
Today they have told us to avoid using public transport in the Osaka area which seems strange given we only have 900+ confirmed cases of which about 200 have been finalised. But seriously if you walk about you would never believe there was a pandemic in full flow... Yesterday I was in Kobe city, people walking about in the city as normal (it is almost impossible to stop Japanese women going shopping), but some shops were closing (it seems voluntary) and today in my area I went to the supermarket and the kids (schools are closed) are all out playing football / volleyball / baseball in the parks whilst the mums are all sat en-masse on mats around the edge having picnic parties..
A few days ago they repeated the aim to hold the Olympics in July? Really? We have tickets but just cannot see how they can start to even consider holding it in July given the numbers globally are climbing the walls at an almost vertical rate and its only 4 months away... Who's going to come (you can't get into Japan as of yesterday from most countries) and how can athletes get ready..
Seriously, if you were not aware of the pandemic and came to Japan the way people are going about their daily lives you would never know we were in the middle of a global pandemic...
I am not sure where else in the world we have Reading fans but would be interesting to read how fans in other countries are being affected by this...
Fascinating insight. The only thing I can say is it may well change very quickly in Japan. I live just outside Cheltenham. This time last week the town was packed out with festival visitors. Fast forward a week and it’s very quiet out there tonight.
by Jagermesiter1871 » 21 Mar 2020 00:04
Sutekh The RFU has ended (not voided) their season for all clubs below the top division (with relegation from the top division already sorted and Newcastle yet to drop a point in the division below that aspect of promotion wouldn’t matter anyway). Could that be a precedent football follows...?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/rugby-union/51974684
For me, I’d rather the football season was just ended as it stands if it was between that or being voided though...
by Zip » 21 Mar 2020 00:06
Jagermesiter1871ZipCape Town Royal Its been interesting reading all your comments and how things are in the UK. I'm in Japan and so far the confirmed numbers have remained fairly stable which is surprising given the number of Chinese tourists that came here up until it all went bang.. However for the 900 or so cases we have here the death rate is about 3.5% which given the quality of the health system here seems high especially when compared to South Korea's low percentage. Maybe its because we have a high percentage of old people and the testing has been lower?
Today they have told us to avoid using public transport in the Osaka area which seems strange given we only have 900+ confirmed cases of which about 200 have been finalised. But seriously if you walk about you would never believe there was a pandemic in full flow... Yesterday I was in Kobe city, people walking about in the city as normal (it is almost impossible to stop Japanese women going shopping), but some shops were closing (it seems voluntary) and today in my area I went to the supermarket and the kids (schools are closed) are all out playing football / volleyball / baseball in the parks whilst the mums are all sat en-masse on mats around the edge having picnic parties..
A few days ago they repeated the aim to hold the Olympics in July? Really? We have tickets but just cannot see how they can start to even consider holding it in July given the numbers globally are climbing the walls at an almost vertical rate and its only 4 months away... Who's going to come (you can't get into Japan as of yesterday from most countries) and how can athletes get ready..
Seriously, if you were not aware of the pandemic and came to Japan the way people are going about their daily lives you would never know we were in the middle of a global pandemic...
I am not sure where else in the world we have Reading fans but would be interesting to read how fans in other countries are being affected by this...
Fascinating insight. The only thing I can say is it may well change very quickly in Japan. I live just outside Cheltenham. This time last week the town was packed out with festival visitors. Fast forward a week and it’s very quiet out there tonight.
Yeh but that seemed criminally stupid at the time.
by windermereROYAL » 21 Mar 2020 00:18
by Jagermesiter1871 » 21 Mar 2020 00:24
windermereROYAL I`m going to be a wreck by the time this is over, no sport, no pubs, no holidays. `I`ll be climbing up the walls this time next week.
by Snowball » 21 Mar 2020 07:31
Jagermesiter1871windermereROYAL I`m going to be a wreck by the time this is over, no sport, no pubs, no holidays. `I`ll be climbing up the walls this time next week.
I already am.
by Millsy » 21 Mar 2020 10:23
by Snowball » 21 Mar 2020 10:41
by Uke » 21 Mar 2020 11:10
2 world wars, 1 world cup Chill.
Way more people have had this virus than we think. YES
We will enter a peak soon and things will slow. YES
Several treatments are already showing promise and vaccines have been produced. NO, testing is only just starting
We will forget about this like we forgot about the other SARS and Ebola etc. NO
Quit stressing about the damned virus. YES, will Carrie be alive at the end of this series of Homeland?
by Jagermesiter1871 » 21 Mar 2020 11:26
SnowballJagermesiter1871windermereROYAL I`m going to be a wreck by the time this is over, no sport, no pubs, no holidays. `I`ll be climbing up the walls this time next week.
I already am.
It is weird. I can imagine mental health issues and suicides adding to the toll.
I spent 24 days in RAF nick when I was about 21 (28, 4 off for good behaviour)
but I got interactions with the MPs, went out on work duties etc. It wasn't as bad
as this, and the situation medium-term looked rosy.
When they let me out to shop I was euphoric for a couple of hours. I showered
and dressed smart-casual rather than my usual sporting crap gear. I wanted to
be "out there", tell myself I was fully alive.
I'm not sure how this oldie/vulnerable lockdown will be phrased, but there is NO way
I could stay indoors for 4-8-12 weeks.
by Millsy » 21 Mar 2020 11:48
Uke2 world wars, 1 world cup Chill.
Way more people have had this virus than we think. YES
We will enter a peak soon and things will slow. YES
Several treatments are already showing promise and vaccines have been produced. NO, testing is only just starting
We will forget about this like we forgot about the other SARS and Ebola etc. NO
Quit stressing about the damned virus. YES, will Carrie be alive at the end of this series of Homeland?
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot], Hendo and 41 guests