Page 1 of 2

Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 11 Nov 2008 22:11
by Sarah Star
He plays left-back or midfield - mainly on the left - and he looked really impressive tonight playing for Arsenal against Wigan in the Carling Cup. He goes forward with pace and defends well.

We nearly went for him earlier this year. Do we need another player like this? And would we still go for him do you think?

I bow to your superior knowledge on the matter.

(Never done one of these threads before. It's quite exciting!)

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 11 Nov 2008 22:14
by AlexY25
He did look quite good.

I liked the look of jay simpson. Went out on loan to millwall last year and did brilliant, and looked even better tonight

Whenever arsenal play a carling cup game, people will be alerted because there all young, and all good.

So many of there players would be great signings (Fabianski, Vela, Wilshere, Ramsey, Gibbs, Song, Simpson)

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 11 Nov 2008 22:18
by Sarah Star
I suppose that means their prices all went up too. :roll:

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 11 Nov 2008 23:18
by PEARCEY
He would be a good signing...one for the future. A bit like Mancienne now on loan at Wolves. He looks like a terrrific young centre half..

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 12 Nov 2008 08:08
by Super Kevin Bremner!
Nobody listened to the commentary then no?

Or watched the game for that matter?

He got ripped apart throughout the whole first half by De Ridder.

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 12 Nov 2008 09:59
by Bill Oddie's Beard
AlexY25 wrote:He did look quite good.

I liked the look of jay simpson. Went out on loan to millwall last year and did brilliant, and looked even better tonight

Whenever arsenal play a carling cup game, people will be alerted because there all young, and all good.

So many of there players would be great signings (Fabianski, Vela, Wilshere, Ramsey, Gibbs, Song, Simpson)
Simpson was Millwall's player of the year and league one player of the year last season, I'm surprised he hasn't been loaned out to a c'ship side this season.

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 12 Nov 2008 10:30
by Sun Tzu
Let's hope Coppell steers clear of loan signings again.

The 106 felt good at least in part because it was OUR team rather than a load of players borrowed from somewhere else (with one small and almost entirely insignificant exception !).

I don't mind us loaning our youngsters out of course, but I'm not at all keen on us shipping in short term players from other clubs.

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 12 Nov 2008 16:09
by Thomas L'Heureux
Super Kevin Bremner! wrote:Nobody listened to the commentary then no?

Or watched the game for that matter?

He got ripped apart throughout the whole first half by De Ridder.
I was at the Emirates last night and I have to agree, he was probably their weakest player alongside Gavin Hoyte. Not great defensively and offered very little in the air.

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 12 Nov 2008 17:15
by Sarah Star
I feel like I was watching a different game now. :roll:

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 12 Nov 2008 17:34
by Platypuss
As if it really needs to be said - KWOOF

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 12 Nov 2008 17:39
by Sarah Star
You love us really!

We don't make sweeping generalisations like saying 'he got ripped apart throughout the whole first half', and we let you sound big and clever like offering you a chance to say 'pace down the left? We might need some of that if SHunt goes'. No one did though :roll:

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 13 Nov 2008 12:22
by brendywendy
well i reckon your contribution is slightly more worth while than platypus' on this thread sarah, so crack on!

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 13 Nov 2008 12:25
by winchester_royal
If Hunt were to leave in January, we could do a lot worse than getting this guy in on loan.

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 13 Nov 2008 12:28
by Hoop Blah
winchester_royal wrote:If Hunt were to leave in January, we could do a lot worse than getting this guy in on loan.
You should probably be asking yourself if we could do any better though!

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 13 Nov 2008 12:44
by winchester_royal
Hoop Blah wrote:
winchester_royal wrote:If Hunt were to leave in January, we could do a lot worse than getting this guy in on loan.
You should probably be asking yourself if we could do any better though!
Not while we are in the chump. Therefore get this guy in for 6 months while we stroll to promotion, and then buy someone long term when we will be a more attractive proposition to players.

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 13 Nov 2008 18:38
by Norfolk Royal
Gibbls was at Norwich on loan last season and it's a big Nooooooooooooooo.

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 13 Nov 2008 18:54
by winchester_royal
Norfolk Royal wrote:Gibbls was at Norwich on loan last season and it's a big Nooooooooooooooo.
'Greed. Coz Glenn Roeder is a much better judge of footballing talent than Arsene Wenger.

:roll:

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 14 Nov 2008 10:47
by ZacNaloen
Wasn't he being played as a left back when he's spent most of his career at left midfield?

That could explain his defensive frailties.

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 16 Nov 2008 14:27
by SCIAG
ZacNaloen wrote:Wasn't he being played as a left back when he's spent most of his career at left midfield?

That could explain his defensive frailties.
Correct, he's a winger.

Re: Speculation - Kieran Gibbs

Posted: 10 Dec 2008 14:57
by gazzer, loyal royal
just seen this thread.

we came very close to signing this lad on loan when surman demanded those stupid wages. He was our plan b until we were told that stretch could be available