by Ian Royal »
14 Dec 2013 16:46
Franchise FC Ian Royal RoyalBlue Maybe now the ALF fans will, albeit reluctantly, acknowledge why Billy Sharp gets to start games.
Yeah, because ALF's got a terrible scoring record!
Sharp's got the shirt, could easily be either of them.
McCarthy saves our blushes.
Alf's record when starting is as bad as his impact from the bench is fantastic. That'll be why Sharp gets to start
(he repeated having now read the rest of the thread
)
Repeating it doesn't make it true. 9 starts 4 goals. 6 subs 3 goals. Basically the same record this season from the bench or from the start. Which is the only season that really matters for judging his performance and when to play him this season.
Feel free to voice your opinion on who's better. But try and make it based on reality, not an oft repeated falacy.
Certainly Sharp gets himself more involved in the game, with more touches per match. But they also average basically the same number of passes a game. And Alf's link up play (when he is involved) is woefully underappreciated by some. As is his general contribution to the club seeing as he's been top scorer (inc this one) three seasons in a row, is also woefully underappreciated by some.
As I said earlier. Sharp has the shirt and is performing well. And that's reflected by pretty much no one picking ALF in their favoured starting line up on here, rightly so. That doesn't mean everyone agrees he's useless starting. Because he isn't.
But anyway. I'd rather be trying to enjoy the game and our lead than trying to take cheap shots at our own players. But then I'm not like RB.