Player Ratings

[floyd__streete]

Jesus wept, are you all so bored now that you are playing top trumps amongst yourselves? FWIW - having admittedly not paid any attention whatsoever to any of these spurious scorecards - I would add that you have all marked Liam Rosnior far too highly in every category.

[SCIAG]

Floyd- I have this for you:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmAv97vCUWw

I know it shouldn't go here but

[Row Z Royal]

I've been asked by 4-4-2 to give individual player ratings for each of our players. I thought I'd see if I could get a general view from you guys rather than giving my own tainted opinion.

So, what d'ya reckon?

TALENTSPOTTER PLAYER RATINGS
Every player needs an overall FourFourTwo rating (1-10), plus individual ratings (also 1-10) for each of their skill categories. Ratings must be whole numbers.

Marcus Hahnemann
Overall ability
Shotstopping
Crosses
Distribution
Saving penalties
Presence
Positioning

Graeme Murty
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Nicky Shorey
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Kalifa Cisse
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Ibrahima Sonko
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Brynjar Gunnarsson
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Leroy Lita
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Kevin Doyle
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Stephen Hunt
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Dave Kitson
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

James Harper
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Ivar Ingimarsson
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Bobby Convey
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling


Liam Rosenior
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Andre Bikey
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Shane Long
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

I'm not reading all that.

[Ian Royal]

Bloody hell, the ratings Royalee used were, bar one or two specifics for a couple of players, surprisingly good.

Theres hope for you yet lad!

[jollyjiminy]

I can do one of these. Being characteristically (and tantalisingly) close to the north goal during the Blackburn game, I can confirm that Stephen Hunt's shooting ability is 0.

[Ian Royal]

I can do one of these. Being characteristically (and tantalisingly) close to the north goal during the Blackburn game, I can confirm that Stephen Hunt's shooting ability is 0.

What on earth do you rate Murty's at if Hunt's is zero. He did manage about 5 or 6 goals in a premiership season. As opposed to Murty's 2 in his Reading Career.

[winchester_royal]

I can do one of these. Being characteristically (and tantalisingly) close to the north goal during the Blackburn game, I can confirm that Stephen Hunt's shooting ability is 0.

What on earth do you rate Murty's at if Hunt's is zero. He did manage about 5 or 6 goals in a premiership season. As opposed to Murty's 2 in his Reading Career.

Yeah, because Murty gets loads of oppurtunities to score at RB

[SCIAG]

If you cant be bothered to do it yourself just tell them where to go

Pretty much why I was hoping you lot would do my dirty work for me...

We could have turned them into top trumps, it was gonna be so much fun

For every one except Marcus.

[Huntley & Palmer]

ALOL @ anyone of our players getting over 7/10, ALOL @ anyone sad enough to actually sit there and work it out

[SCIAG]

ALOL @ anyone of our players getting over 7/10, ALOL @ anyone sad enough to actually sit there and work it out

In the Championship, most of them deserve that or more. I'd be behind you if we were still in the Premier League.

[kadzidlo]

Marcus Hahnemann
Overall ability 7
Shotstopping 8
Crosses 6
Distribution 6
Saving penalties 5
Presence 6
Positioning 8

Graeme Murty
Overall ability 6
Shooting 2
Passing 5
Crossing 5
Tackling 6
Pace 5
Work-rate 7
Creativity 4
Heading 3
Dribbling 5

Nicky Shorey
Overall ability 8
Shooting 7
Passing 8
Crossing 8
Tackling 6
Pace 6
Work-rate 6
Creativity 8
Heading 3
Dribbling 8

Kalifa Cisse
Overall ability 6
Shooting 6
Passing 6
Crossing 6
Tackling 7
Pace 9
Work-rate 7
Creativity 6
Heading 7
Dribbling 6

Ibrahima Sonko
Overall ability 6
Shooting 4
Passing 4
Crossing 3
Tackling 7
Pace 8
Work-rate 7
Creativity 4
Heading 8
Dribbling 3

Brynjar Gunnarsson
Overall ability 5
Shooting 6
Passing 6
Crossing 4
Tackling 6
Pace 3
Work-rate 6
Creativity 4
Heading 6
Dribbling 4

Leroy Lita
Overall ability 6
Shooting 7
Passing 4
Crossing 4
Tackling 3
Pace 7
Work-rate 5
Creativity 5
Heading 7
Dribbling 7

Kevin Doyle
Overall ability 8
Shooting 8
Passing 5
Crossing 6
Tackling 4
Pace 7
Work-rate 9
Creativity 5
Heading 8
Dribbling 6

Stephen Hunt
Overall ability 7
Shooting 6
Passing 6
Crossing 6
Tackling 6
Pace 6
Work-rate 9
Creativity 7
Heading 5
Dribbling 7

Dave Kitson
Overall ability 7
Shooting 7
Passing 6
Crossing 5
Tackling 6
Pace 6
Work-rate 6
Creativity 8
Heading 7
Dribbling 6

James Harper
Overall ability 7
Shooting 7
Passing 7
Crossing 6
Tackling 5
Pace 8
Work-rate 10
Creativity 6
Heading 5
Dribbling 7

Ivar Ingimarsson
Overall ability 5
Shooting 4
Passing 4
Crossing 3
Tackling 6
Pace 4
Work-rate 4
Creativity 3
Heading 7
Dribbling 3

Bobby Convey
Overall ability 7
Shooting 7
Passing 7
Crossing 7
Tackling 5
Pace 6
Work-rate 6
Creativity 7
Heading 4
Dribbling 7


Liam Rosenior
Overall ability 6
Shooting 4
Passing 5
Crossing 5
Tackling 6
Pace 7
Work-rate 6
Creativity 5
Heading 5
Dribbling 5

Andre Bikey
Overall ability 7
Shooting 6
Passing 6
Crossing 4
Tackling 8
Pace 8
Work-rate 6
Creativity 6
Heading 7
Dribbling 5

Shane Long
Overall ability 6
Shooting 6
Passing 5
Crossing 5
Tackling 4
Pace 8
Work-rate 7
Creativity 6
Heading 6
Dribbling 6

[jollyjiminy]

I can do one of these. Being characteristically (and tantalisingly) close to the north goal during the Blackburn game, I can confirm that Stephen Hunt's shooting ability is 0.

What on earth do you rate Murty's at if Hunt's is zero. He did manage about 5 or 6 goals in a premiership season. As opposed to Murty's 2 in his Reading Career.

Yeah, because Murty gets loads of oppurtunities to score at RB

Good replies by one and all, and most astute observations. Indeed, Murty's shooting ability has to score at a lowly 0. However, he is most certainly a good egg, and I've been looking for something to score him highly on, but I can't find a 'huff and puff' category.

[brendywendy]

as a percentage id say his shooting accuracy wasnt that bad-whenever ive seen him have a go - its usually in target, and often pretty fierce
just doesnt happen very often
i was marking the technique-rather than the frequency
same with litas tackling

just cos someone never does it-doesnt mean he cant

[papereyes]

Good replies by one and all, and most astute observations. Indeed, Murty's shooting ability has to score at a lowly 0. However, he is most certainly a good egg, and I've been looking for something to score him highly on, but I can't find a 'huff and puff' category.

"red faced and blowing out of his arse" - 10

[brendywendy]

o those saying ive marked too highly
i think it depends on what the range is
if its all of humanity-then all professional footballers should be 8, 9, 10 for everything, for instance
0 being the ability of a three year old child

or the range i used

if its from all levels of pro football then the prem players should be 8/9/10s
championship 6/7/8s
1st div 4/5/6 etc
0 being the level of semi pro football

this info is key before judging any of the marks given

[Ian Royal]

o those saying ive marked too highly
i think it depends on what the range is
if its all of humanity-then all professional footballers should be 8, 9, 10 for everything, for instance
0 being the ability of a three year old child

or the range i used

if its from all levels of pro football then the prem players should be 8/9/10s
championship 6/7/8s
1st div 4/5/6 etc
0 being the level of semi pro football

this info is key before judging any of the marks given

Mine are based solely on my assessment of Championship level players and my belief that 10 is basically unachievable.

[Chaney]

ayone that gives Marcus 6 and over for distribution wants their heads looking at

[Cookie]

TALENTSPOTTER PLAYER RATINGS

Marcus Hahnemann
Overall ability 6
Shotstopping 9
Crosses (what??)
Distribution 7
Saving penalties 7
Presence 9
Positioning 7

Graeme Murty
Overall ability 6
Shooting 5
Passing 7
Crossing 7
Tackling 8
Pace 7
Work-rate 9
Creativity 6
Heading 8
Dribbling 7

Nicky Shorey
Overall ability 9
Shooting 9
Passing 8
Crossing 10
Tackling 8
Pace 7
Work-rate 5
Creativity 9
Heading 7
Dribbling 9

Kalifa Cisse
Overall ability 6
Shooting 7
Passing 6
Crossing 6
Tackling 8 (based on Man U game)
Pace 7
Work-rate 7
Creativity 7
Heading 5
Dribbling 7

Ibrahima Sonko
Overall ability 6
Shooting 6
Passing 6
Crossing 6
Tackling 8
Pace 6
Work-rate 6
Creativity 4
Heading 8
Dribbling 5

Brynjar Gunnarsson
Overall ability 6
Shooting 7
Passing 7
Crossing 7
Tackling 8
Pace 7
Work-rate 9
Creativity 6
Heading 7
Dribbling 7

Leroy Lita
Overall ability 7
Shooting 7
Passing 7
Crossing 7
Tackling 6
Pace 8
Work-rate 7
Creativity 7
Heading 7
Dribbling 7

Kevin Doyle
Overall ability 7
Shooting 6
Passing 8
Crossing 8
Tackling 7
Pace 9
Work-rate 10
Creativity 7
Heading 8
Dribbling 8

Stephen Hunt
Overall ability 6
Shooting 7
Passing 6
Crossing 7
Tackling 8
Pace 7
Work-rate 9
Creativity 4
Heading 6
Dribbling 7

Dave Kitson
Overall ability 7
Shooting 7
Passing 7
Crossing 5
Tackling 3
Pace 5
Work-rate 6
Creativity 8
Heading 8
Dribbling 7

James Harper
Overall ability 8
Shooting 9
Passing 9
Crossing 8
Tackling 4
Pace 8
Work-rate 9
Creativity 7
Heading 5
Dribbling 7

Ivar Ingimarsson
Overall ability 8
Shooting 5
Passing 6
Crossing 6
Tackling 9
Pace 7
Work-rate 9
Creativity 7
Heading 9
Dribbling 7

Bobby Convey
Overall ability 7
Shooting 7
Passing 7
Crossing 8
Tackling 6
Pace 6
Work-rate 6
Creativity 7
Heading 4
Dribbling 6


Liam Rosenior
Overall ability 7
Shooting 6
Passing 6
Crossing 6
Tackling 7
Pace 7
Work-rate 8
Creativity 7
Heading 6
Dribbling 7

Andre Bikey
Overall ability 8
Shooting 6
Passing 6
Crossing 7
Tackling 8
Pace 9
Work-rate 8
Creativity 7
Heading 10
Dribbling 7

Shane Long
Overall ability 6
Shooting 7
Passing 6
Crossing 7
Tackling 6
Pace 7
Work-rate 8
Creativity 7
Heading 7
Dribbling 6

Marek Matejovsky
Overall ability 9
Shooting 8
Passing 9
Crossing 8
Tackling 5
Pace 7
Work-rate 7
Creativity 9
Heading 6
Dribbling 7

Michael Duberry
Overall ability 7
Shooting 7
Passing 7
Crossing 6
Tackling 8
Pace 7
Work-rate 8
Creativity 7
Heading 9
Dribbling 7

John Oster
Overall ability 7
Shooting 6
Passing 6
Crossing 7
Tackling 6
Pace 7
Work-rate 5
Creativity 7
Heading 5
Dribbling 8

Reading Fans No.13
Overall ability 11
Shooting 0
Passing 0
Crossing 0
Tackling 0
Pace 0
Work-rate 11
Creativity 5
Heading 0
Drooling 9

[bikey_is_god!]

Marcus Hahnemann
Overall ability- 7
Shotstopping- 8
Crosses- 5
Distribution- 2
Saving penalties- 5
Presence- 7
Positioning- 7

Graeme Murty
Overall ability- 4
Shooting-3
Passing- 6
Crossing- 6
Tackling-5
Pace-3
Work-rate- 10
Creativity- 4
Heading- 2
Dribbling- 5

Nicky Shorey
Overall ability-7
Shooting- 6
Passing- 7
Crossing- 7
Tackling- 6
Pace- 6
Work-rate- 5
Creativity- 6
Heading- 3
Dribbling- 7

Kalifa Cisse
Overall ability- 6
Shooting- 5
Passing- 6
Crossing- 5
Tackling- 7
Pace- 6
Work-rate- 6
Creativity- 5
Heading-4
Dribbling- 5

Ibrahima Sonko
Overall ability- 6
Shooting-3
Passing- 4
Crossing- 2
Tackling- 7 (3 atm)
Pace- 5
Work-rate- 7
Creativity- 2
Heading- 10
Dribbling- 3

Brynjar Gunnarsson
Overall ability- 5
Shooting- 6
Passing- 6
Crossing- 4
Tackling- 5
Pace- 2
Work-rate- 6
Creativity- 3
Heading- 5
Dribbling- 3

Leroy Lita
Overall ability- 6
Shooting- 7
Passing- 5
Crossing- 4
Tackling- 3
Pace- 6
Work-rate- 7
Creativity- 4(with occasional flashes of brilliance)
Heading- 3
Dribbling- 5

Kevin Doyle
Overall ability- 7
Shooting- 8
Passing- 6
Crossing- 4
Tackling- 4
Pace- 6
Work-rate- 7
Creativity- 6
Heading- 7
Dribbling- 7

Stephen Hunt
Overall ability- 5
Shooting- 4
Passing- 6
Crossing- 5
Tackling- 3
Pace- 5
Work-rate- 10
Creativity- 7
Heading- 7
Dribbling- 6

Dave Kitson
Overall ability-7
Shooting- 8
Passing- 6
Crossing- 4
Tackling- 6
Pace- 4
Work-rate- 8
Creativity- 5
Heading- 7
Dribbling- 7

James Harper
Overall ability- 6
Shooting- 6
Passing-7
Crossing- 6
Tackling- 5
Pace- 6
Work-rate- 8
Creativity- 6
Heading- 3
Dribbling- 6

Ivar Ingimarsson
Overall ability- 6
Shooting- 3
Passing- 5
Crossing- 2
Tackling- 8
Pace- 5
Work-rate- 7
Creativity- 3
Heading- 8
Dribbling- 3

Bobby Convey
Overall ability- 7
Shooting- 6
Passing- 7
Crossing- 7.
Tackling- 3
Pace- 6
Work-rate- 6
Creativity- 7.
Heading- 4
Dribbling- 7.


Liam Rosenior
Overall ability- 6
Shooting- 5
Passing- 6
Crossing- 6
Tackling- 5
Pace- 7
Work-rate- 6
Creativity- 4
Heading- 4
Dribbling- 6

Andre Bikey
Overall ability- 8
Shooting- 7
Passing- 6
Crossing- 5
Tackling- 8
Pace- 7
Work-rate- 7
Creativity- 7
Heading- 8
Dribbling- 8

Shane Long
Overall ability- 6
Shooting- 7
Passing- 7
Crossing- 3
Tackling- 3
Pace- 7
Work-rate- 7
Creativity- 6
Heading- 6
Dribbling- 6

Marek
Overall ability- 8
Shooting- 6
Passing- 9
Crossing- 5
Tackling- 2
Pace- 5
Work-rate- 6
Creativity- 9
Heading- 3
Dribbling- 6

basically i did them as if:
1 is awful
2-very poor
3- poor
4- not great
5- a few concerns
6- ok
7- good
8- very good
9- outstanding
10- out of this world (e.g never getting beaten in the air, putting away every chance or never missing a tackle)

[floyd__streete]