RUMOUR - Paul McShane

[brendywendy]

God no. Remember seeing him play for Sunderland against us and he was utter shite. Shouldn't write him off over one performance I guess but the fact he's not good enough for Hull speaks volumes.

what about some of our greatest ever players who werent considered good enough for brentford etc before they came here and became legends

[brendywendy]

Paul Shane > Paul McShane

ian mcshane>>>paul shane>>>paul mcshane

[roadrunner]

Please god no. We'd be better off giving a youngster a chance instead!

[holsgrove breaks a leg]

Oh for gods sake please no, turning circle of a tank and likely to give away more OG's than ivar.Hoping the 30k wages are a turn off, i think Killgallon is a better bet

[Sarah Star]

Paul Shane > Paul McShane

ian mcshane>>>paul shane>>>paul mcshane

He'd be deadwood in our team.

[DOYLERSAROYALER]

Oh for gods sake please no, turning circle of a tank and likely to give away more OG's than ivar.Hoping the 30k wages are a turn off, i think Killgallon is a better bet

Good shout ....

[roadrunner]

Oh for gods sake please no, turning circle of a tank and likely to give away more OG's than ivar.Hoping the 30k wages are a turn off, i think Killgallon is a better bet

Good shout ....

This!

[BR2]

God no. Remember seeing him play for Sunderland against us and he was utter shite. Shouldn't write him off over one performance I guess but the fact he's not good enough for Hull speaks volumes.

what about some of our greatest ever players who werent considered good enough for brentford etc before they came here and became legends

Nothing like the same.
McShane was a failed Man Utd youngster who has somehow persuaded a number of clubs that he could be quite good and then flopped with them.
The Brentford lot were mainly lower league players that Coppell knew very well and managed to get the very best from and as a bonus for us cost f*** all .
Please don't let us get McShane.

[brendywendy]

sidwell was a failed arsenal youngster who went round to various clubs before coming to us

the rest were released on frees from even worse clubs cos no one wanted them.

how is it different

[DOYLERSAROYALER]

sidwell was a failed arsenal youngster who went round to various clubs before coming to us

the rest were released on frees from even worse clubs cos no one wanted them.

how is it different

Brendy ...simple....Sidwell CAN play football

[brendywendy]

not saying he can- simply saying that being bombed out of a top four club, not getting signed up instantly, is not a fool proof indicator of non-quality

[Snowball]

not saying he can- simply saying that being bombed out of a top four club, not getting signed up instantly, is not a fool proof indicator of non-quality

Brendy, did you watch that You-Tube video.

I know highlights (in this case lowlights) can be distorting
but what is there is HORRIBLE

[brendywendy]

lol

nah.


but im not saying hes great, or that we should buy him.

just pointingout the flaws in the arguments used to say he was shit and we shouldnt buy him

[peterroyal76]

NO NO NO NO NO NO!!!!!!!!!!!

[Royalwaster]

NO NO NO NO NO NO!!!!!!!!!!!

That's what people said when we signed Ian Harte too ... and also some when we got Leigertwood on loan, so in McD I trust.

[LoyalRoyal22]

no thanks

[peterroyal76]

NO NO NO NO NO NO!!!!!!!!!!!

That's what people said when we signed Ian Harte too ... and also some when we got Leigertwood on loan, so in McD I trust.

It maybe what some people said, but I didn't say it.

Paul McShane is utter shite, the only thing he has in common with Harte is they are both Irish.

[Mike Hunt]

if the club pays this guy 30K a week - I will have grave doubts of a "well run club"

[Royalwaster]

Truth is we're no signing anyone, so no need to shout.

[brendywendy]

if the club pays this guy 30K a week - I will have grave doubts of a "well run club"

luckily for you we wont be paying anyone 30K a week, and probably not much more half that either