Hoop BlahKC Royal He's probably better than a Conference South keeper, and he did pretty well against one of the top teams Sutton in highlights I saw, but I thought it was a pretty damning assessment of his Reading future him dropping down that low to get some games.
Both Federici and McCarthy went down into the same kind of level at similar ages to get games. Doesn't seem to have prevented them from being Champship keepers.
With keepers they almost have to go lower down to start with because they're not going to get 10/20 minute sub appearances to stake their claim for a starting place like an outfield player can.
In the last year we seem to have changed our policy with sending players out on loan, preferring to develop them at the club instead. I don't think it's a coincidence that the young players released were ones who had been on loan during the season (can't remember without checking if this was the case with all of them but it seemed to be). Maybe i'm writing him off prematurely, he's still very young and inexperienced for a keeper, but I just think if the club rated him after he started the season in the U21 team he would have stayed there for the rest of the season, and we would have sent another young keeper out on loan instead to get experience. He also wouldn't have gone out on loan to Oxford and not play if he was likely to be able to step up. I think my issue with it was that he had to drop down two divisions from there just to get games. I do appreciate though that Fed played for Maidenhead once upon a time before he was part of the first team squad, i'd also forgotten about McCarthy until someone mentioned it earlier.
One thing I do wonder that i'd forgotten to add. If we'd known how good McCarthy was going to become would we have signed Andersen? Their career seemed to be following a similar path until McCarthy started playing in the first team (certainly in the last season when they were both on loan anyway). Without McCarthy, Andersen may well have had decent opportunities to play by now and his development as a result maybe has been stunted because of McCarthy.