by tmesis »
28 Aug 2026 21:38
28 Aug 2026 21:38
Sutekh wrote: ↑28 Aug 2026 08:32
tmesis wrote: ↑28 Aug 2026 07:58
Clyde1998 wrote: ↑27 Aug 2026 21:01
Arguably, Brighton were always held back by their lack of a proper stadium. They were consistently getting 25,000+ in their new ground in the Championship before promotion.
They did the bit we didn't manage to do: stay in the Premier League for long enough to become an established side. Had we stayed up in 2008, there's little reason we couldn't have ended up in a similar position to them now with the trajectory we were on.
Brentford and Bournemouth are the two which really hit home what impact good owners can have. Bournemouth did chuck a lot of money at getting to the Premier League initially (whereas Brentford were a lot more strategic), but both have turned themselves into top-half Premier League sides. Since Madejski left, we've had okay owners at best and two terrible owners.
It's wierd. The most important aspect of any club is recruitment. Apart from bankrolled clubs, point to any club punching above its weight, and all of them know how to find players on a budget. Any yet we are conditioned to always think it's about getting another new manager, and an owner who'll spend millions.
Bournemouth were bankrolled, Brighton were also to a degree though think they were more a bit from both camps. Brentford were more a high level of shrewd recruitment as they had finances to support what their managers needed and more, plus a shiny new stadium and facilities to impress.
Reading were the prime example of shrewd recruitment on a budget being successful, built a 106 point season on that, a points tally that will never be beaten in any division, apart from by clubs bankrolling their way through stacks of players to good for the level.
Trouble is Reading carried on with that approach in the PL and then chose to be cheap at exactly the wrong time so it was always going to be the end of that after the short sojourn.
Bournemouth were definitely bankrolled, but have learned to buy well.
As great as recruitment was for Reading 20 years ago, we also benefitted quite a lot on players known to Steve Coppell. When we got to the premier league, I don't think we signed a single player who improved the team. While it's tempting to say if we'd stayed up in 2007/8 (or come straight back up in 2008/9) we could have had a decent run in the top flight, we would have needed to up our game in terms of recuitment to do so.
The likes of Bournemouth, Brighton and Brentford are also fortunate to have gone up just as the they money in the premier league went through the roof. It's much harder for clubs going up to have enough time to build a competitive side now, and if clubs go down, they are much more likely to get back at the first time of asking. Not that that's relevant to Reading today. This feels like the early 90s, when a return to the 2nd tier looked years away, let alone getting back to the top flight.