CONFIMRED - Blackman to Derby

[No Fixed Abode]

Why? It's a valid point.

Also - if Blackman wasn't that good and somebody could have come in and done an equally good job, why didn't they?

It's all conjecture of course. I just don't get this attitude of "He's gone, he wasn't that good anyway". Especially as he's been one of Reading's better players this season.

I will take mark twain's advice to never argue with a stupid person (aka you), as they will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience

Ok - so to clarify. You're saying Real would be as good or better without Ronaldo. Barca would be as good or better without Messi. Never argue with a stupid person indeed.

[Winston Smith]

LOL @ Kes

[No Fixed Abode]

Well. Let's see if I'm correct. About half a season to go. If Blackman's replacement comes in and does better I'll take back everything I said.

[melonhead]

Well. Let's see if I'm correct. .

ill save you the bother

About half a season to go. If Blackman's replacement comes in a does better I'll take back everything I said

he doesn't have to do better. by your logic, hed have to contribute absolutely nothing whatsoever.(still possible)

[Winston Smith]

Well. Let's see if I'm correct. .

ill save you the bother

[No Fixed Abode]

Well. Let's see if I'm correct. .

ill save you the bother

About half a season to go. If Blackman's replacement comes in a does better I'll take back everything I said

he doesn't have to do better. by your logic, hed have to contribute absolutely nothing whatsoever.(still possible)

You've got the wrong end of the stick here Brendy.

I'm saying Reading will miss Blackman's contribution to the team in terms of goals and assists. Other people on here are saying he won't be missed. So of course his replacement has to do better to prove me wrong.

[Extended-Phenotype]

Yeah you are going to have to dumb that down a lot further for him before it clicks

Just say 'no' m8!

You wouldn't hear me if I did, according to your sis m8

[WoodleyRoyal]

Yeah you are going to have to dumb that down a lot further for him before it clicks

Just say 'no' m8!

You wouldn't hear me if I did, according to your sis m8

power post

[No Fixed Abode]

Yeah you are going to have to dumb that down a lot further for him before it clicks

Just say 'no' m8!

You wouldn't hear me if I did, according to your sis m8

I thought you didn't troll m8? Take a look at yourself.

[TBM]

Ok - so to clarify. You're saying Real would be as good or better without Ronaldo. Barca would be as good or better without Messi. Never argue with a stupid person indeed.

Those players give those teams an extra "edge" - Blackman didn't really do that for us, as really all he did was score 11 goals. You can't say "where would you be without his goals" as Clarke would have gone out and found someone to be our 25 goals a season man, he didn't need to as he saw enough in Blackman in the summer to believe in him.

So yeah if you just physically just remove him and his goals we would be lower however if you replaced him with someone else just as capable we could be higher and they could have more goals than what he got.

[No Fixed Abode]

Yeah you are going to have to dumb that down a lot further for him before it clicks

Just say 'no' m8!

power post

[TFF]

Well. Let's see if I'm correct. .

ill save you the bother

About half a season to go. If Blackman's replacement comes in a does better I'll take back everything I said

he doesn't have to do better. by your logic, hed have to contribute absolutely nothing whatsoever.(still possible)

You've got the wrong end of the stick here Brendy.

I'm saying Reading will miss Blackman's contribution to the team in terms of goals and assists. Other people on here are saying he won't be missed. So of course his replacement has to do better to prove me wrong.

How do you know that if Blackman was still in the team he'd be scoring the goals that someone else isn't?

eh?

[Winston Smith]

Can we HoF these last couple of pages?

[Pepe the Horseman]

Well. Let's see if I'm correct. .

ill save you the bother

About half a season to go. If Blackman's replacement comes in a does better I'll take back everything I said

he doesn't have to do better. by your logic, hed have to contribute absolutely nothing whatsoever.(still possible)

You've got the wrong end of the stick here Brendy.

I'm saying Reading will miss Blackman's contribution to the team in terms of goals and assists. Other people on here are saying he won't be missed. So of course his replacement has to do better to prove me wrong.

So if we finish above 12th will you admit you're wrong and apologise to everyone?

[LWJ]

Well. Let's see if I'm correct. About half a season to go. If Blackman's replacement comes in and does better I'll take back everything I said.

So if we finish above 12th you will have been wrong? As that's where Blackman's contribution has got us?


£100 to a charity Kes?*



*No Dirko

[LWJ]

So if we finish above 12th will you admit you're wrong and apologise to everyone?

[No Fixed Abode]

Well. Let's see if I'm correct. About half a season to go. If Blackman's replacement comes in and does better I'll take back everything I said.

So if we finish above 12th you will have been wrong? As that's where Blackman's contribution has got us?


£100 to a charity Kes?*



*No Dirko

Blackman's contribution may have got you above 12th if the likes of Al-Hasbi or Bond didn't throw it in the net every few games.

[Pepe the Horseman]

So if we finish above 12th will you admit you're wrong and apologise to everyone?

on a level bruv

[LWJ]

Well. Let's see if I'm correct. About half a season to go. If Blackman's replacement comes in and does better I'll take back everything I said.

So if we finish above 12th you will have been wrong? As that's where Blackman's contribution has got us?


£100 to a charity Kes?*



*No Dirko

Blackman's contribution may have got you above 12th if the likes of Al-Hasbi or Bond didn't throw it in the net every few games.

[LWJ]

So if we finish above 12th will you admit you're wrong and apologise to everyone?

on a level bruv

gr8 minds m8