Marcus Hahnemann > Shaka Hislop > Adam Federici

[John Madejski's Wallet]

Feds isn't in our top 5

Shaka>Martinez>Marcus for me

That said, the only keeper I've seen us have where the the oppo running through 1on1 with our keeper, didnt instantly make me think 'goal', was Marcus.

[Dirk Gently]

Probably the most remarkable goalkeeping performance I’ve seen from a Reading goalkeeper was Simon Shepard away at Leicester

One of the great "I was there" moments in Reading FC history.
I still can't believe just how bad Shepard was in general, we can't have had many worse keepers ever can we?

I'll give you Scott Howie away at Wycombe in October 1999. Substituted at half-time and replaced by Peter van der Kwaak.

But in we include loanees, Nick Colgan takes the award. Five games for us in 1998, his first action in a Reading shirt, away at Crewe, was to pick the ball up from a throw-in and concede a free-kick. Later he delayed a clearance and was charged down to concede the only goal.

Then his next 4 matches were : 1-5, 0-3, 0-4, 0-5 to give PL : 5, W: 0, D: 0, GF: 1, GA : 18. Pts : 0.

[stealthpapes]

Probably the most remarkable goalkeeping performance I’ve seen from a Reading goalkeeper was Simon Shepard away at Leicester

One of the great "I was there" moments in Reading FC history.
I still can't believe just how bad Shepard was in general, we can't have had many worse keepers ever can we?

I'll give you Scott Howie away at Wycombe in October 1999. Substituted at half-time and replaced by Peter van der Kwaak.

But in we include loanees, Nick Colgan takes the award. Five games for us in 1998, his first action in a Reading shirt, away at Crewe, was to pick the ball up from a throw-in and concede a free-kick. Later he delayed a clearance and was charged down to concede the only goal.

Then his next 4 matches were : 1-5, 0-3, 0-4, 0-5 to give PL : 5, W: 0, D: 0, GF: 1, GA : 18. Pts : 0.

genuine LOL at GF1 there - an effort was made.

[Dirk Gently]

One of the great "I was there" moments in Reading FC history.
I still can't believe just how bad Shepard was in general, we can't have had many worse keepers ever can we?

I'll give you Scott Howie away at Wycombe in October 1999. Substituted at half-time and replaced by Peter van der Kwaak.

But in we include loanees, Nick Colgan takes the award. Five games for us in 1998, his first action in a Reading shirt, away at Crewe, was to pick the ball up from a throw-in and concede a free-kick. Later he delayed a clearance and was charged down to concede the only goal.

Then his next 4 matches were : 1-5, 0-3, 0-4, 0-5 to give PL : 5, W: 0, D: 0, GF: 1, GA : 18. Pts : 0.

genuine LOL at GF1 there - an effort was made.

A Skittles penalty when already 5-0 down at Stockport.

[Orion1871]

Martinez not here long enough. Plus, the success has gone to his head and he's a complete arsehole.

Have to include Al Habsi as he had the best single season I've seen a keeper have.

So for me it's:

Shaka > Hahnemann > Al Habsi

[Forbury Lion]

Do you agree? Discuss

Phil Whitehead has just thrown his gloves off and stormed down the tunnel in protest (again).