Player of the season 24/25

[Brogue]

It's that time again folks with 5 games to go who is your player of the season?

All players chosen have 10 appearances or more, data taken from transfer market, list sorted by number of appearances.

[rabidbee]

This is surely a straight-up shoot out between Bindon and Knibbs? As Harvey is my 7yo’s favourite, I’ll go with him (although I actually think it’s Bindon).

[Brogue]

This is surely a straight-up shoot out between Bindon and Knibbs? As Harvey is my 7yo’s favourite, I’ll go with him (although I actually think it’s Bindon).

Agreed, although I think Pereira needs an honourable mention.

[Hendo]

Bindon
Knibbs
Savage

[MartinRdg]

Bindon
Knibbs
Savage

Pereira, Mbengue and Wing?

[Hendo]

Bindon
Knibbs
Savage

Pereira, Mbengue and Wing?

Are not in my top 3 players of the season.

[rabidbee]

All of the players already mentioned have been great, because it’s been a great team effort. But Bindon, and then Knibbs, have been the star performers.

Where would Smith have placed on people’s lists if he had stayed?

[LUX]

I had a bit of a man crush on Smith.

Bindon is clearly top class, Pereira, Mbengue and Knibbs have been magnificent. Savage mostly too.

My choice? Knibbs for the goals.

[Silver Fox]

It's between Mbengue and Bindon for me, Bindon is better but he's no longer "ours" so Mbengue gets the vote

[Armadillo Roadkill]

What's different this season is there are many good candidates. At least six should be in contention:

Bindon
Pereira
Mbengue
Knibbs
Savage
Craig

It has to be Bindon though.

[MartinRdg]

What's different this season is there are many good candidates. At least six should be in contention:

Bindon
Pereira
Mbengue
Knibbs
Savage
Craig

It has to be Bindon though.

Interesting thought on selecting Craig - would have loved to have seen him in a midfield role rather than full-back. Not sure I would select him for POS for his time at full back but it's all about opinions.....

[Sutekh]

What was the top 3 last year.

[Whore Jackie]

What's different this season is there are many good candidates. At least six should be in contention:

Bindon
Pereira
Mbengue
Knibbs
Savage
Craig

It has to be Bindon though.

Would agree with this, although the improvement in Savage has been exceptional this season. Not even a regular starter last season. Bindon, Pereira, Mbengue and Knibbs have been excellent for us pretty much since they signed.

[leon]

It's got to be The Knibbler.

Followed closely by Bindon and then Pereira.

[Brogue]

What was the top 3 last year.

https://hobnob.royals.org/forum/viewtop ... n#p5479460

[Hound]

Bindon
Knibbs
Savage

Yeah prob my top 3 in that order

[andrew1957]

Tough one as so many players have performed above expectations this season. I think Craig and Elliot both did well until they were injured. And as people have mentioned the likes of Knibbs, Savage, Wing, Mbengue etc have all been magnificent but Bindon has probably been the stand out player. Perhaps “when” we get promoted, Forest will allow him to come back to us on loan in the Championship.

[WestYorksRoyal]

Too much choice, makes a change from the old days where we had a default winner every year. I'd say Knibbs, Bindon, Pereira, Savage in that order, with the rest some way off.

[From Despair To Where?]

It's clearly Bindon but given the way the season has panned out both on and off the field, it feels almost churlish to single anyone out.

[Biscuit goalie]

Make it players of the season. I vote all of them Plus Selles and Hunty