by Elm Park Kid » 14 Sep 2019 17:21
14 Sep 2019 17:21by Sutekh » 14 Sep 2019 17:21
14 Sep 2019 17:21Apparently Reading have gone behind first 10 times under JG and lost 9windermereROYAL wrote:Wigan yes,Jagermesiter1871 wrote:Didn't we numerous times at the end of last season?windermereROYAL wrote:
When was the last time we came from behind to win a league game? damned if i remember it.
by URZZZZ » 14 Sep 2019 17:30
14 Sep 2019 17:30Meite gets an easy ride by so many people. Boye seems to be an easy victim so far. Boye is miles better than Meitesandman wrote:Couple of well taken goals against Cardiff and that's it. If a player like Meite had missed some of the chances Puscas has in the last few games he'd have been criticised non stop by many.Zip wrote:It’s a huge problem. Look at West Brom in comparison. I’m not getting the hype for Puscas either.Hound wrote:
Yep. Particularly concerned that we’ve lost every game after conceding first in the league
by Jagermesiter1871 » 14 Sep 2019 17:31
14 Sep 2019 17:31Yeh I would say in terms of end product theres little in it between the 2.URZZZZ wrote:Meite gets an easy ride by so many people. Boye seems to be an easy victim so far. Boye is miles better than Meitesandman wrote:Couple of well taken goals against Cardiff and that's it. If a player like Meite had missed some of the chances Puscas has in the last few games he'd have been criticised non stop by many.Zip wrote:
It’s a huge problem. Look at West Brom in comparison. I’m not getting the hype for Puscas either.
by sandman » 14 Sep 2019 17:35
14 Sep 2019 17:35No he's not.URZZZZ wrote:Meite gets an easy ride by so many people. Boye seems to be an easy victim so far. Boye is miles better than Meitesandman wrote:Couple of well taken goals against Cardiff and that's it. If a player like Meite had missed some of the chances Puscas has in the last few games he'd have been criticised non stop by many.Zip wrote:
It’s a huge problem. Look at West Brom in comparison. I’m not getting the hype for Puscas either.
by Zip » 14 Sep 2019 17:43
14 Sep 2019 17:43Amen to that. Meite scored 13 goals in a struggling outfit last season and the majority were very well taken.sandman wrote:No he's not.URZZZZ wrote:Meite gets an easy ride by so many people. Boye seems to be an easy victim so far. Boye is miles better than Meitesandman wrote:
Couple of well taken goals against Cardiff and that's it. If a player like Meite had missed some of the chances Puscas has in the last few games he'd have been criticised non stop by many.
People recognise Meite has limitations. You just have such a hard on for hating him that you think that people who have a more realistic and not as extreme view as yours of his weaknesses give him an easy ride.
by Zip » 14 Sep 2019 17:44
14 Sep 2019 17:44So a continuation of what happened under Clement and the second season under Stam.Sutekh wrote:Apparently Reading have gone behind first 10 times under JG and lost 9windermereROYAL wrote:Wigan yes,Jagermesiter1871 wrote:
Didn't we numerous times at the end of last season?
by Dick Habbin's hairdo » 14 Sep 2019 17:48
14 Sep 2019 17:48by URZZZZ » 14 Sep 2019 18:03
14 Sep 2019 18:03We barely came from behind under Stam’s first season eitherZip wrote:So a continuation of what happened under Clement and the second season under Stam.Sutekh wrote:Apparently Reading have gone behind first 10 times under JG and lost 9windermereROYAL wrote:
Wigan yes,
by windermereROYAL » 14 Sep 2019 18:08
14 Sep 2019 18:08by Ascotexgunner » 14 Sep 2019 18:11
14 Sep 2019 18:11by URZZZZ » 14 Sep 2019 18:14
14 Sep 2019 18:14I don’t hate Meite. I hate players who clearly don’t give their all. He works hard but he’s extremely limited and the record for him starting right now is 0-0-3sandman wrote:No he's not.URZZZZ wrote:Meite gets an easy ride by so many people. Boye seems to be an easy victim so far. Boye is miles better than Meitesandman wrote:
Couple of well taken goals against Cardiff and that's it. If a player like Meite had missed some of the chances Puscas has in the last few games he'd have been criticised non stop by many.
People recognise Meite has limitations. You just have such a hard on for hating him that you think that people who have a more realistic and not as extreme view as yours of his weaknesses give him an easy ride.
by Hound » 14 Sep 2019 18:17
14 Sep 2019 18:17by paddy20 » 14 Sep 2019 18:31
14 Sep 2019 18:31by krapmle » 14 Sep 2019 19:54
14 Sep 2019 19:54by URZZZZ » 14 Sep 2019 19:59
14 Sep 2019 19:59Yep. Also would have kept McNulty too. But he’s done here, and it’s a crying shame because he’s playing well at Sunderland so far. He’s a different option like BaldockHound wrote:I share your frustration with Baldock urrzzz
I could really see him being useful playing with Puscas or Joao. The others too similar
by Snowflake Royal » 14 Sep 2019 22:07
14 Sep 2019 22:07Yeah that's nonsense from Urz who has a real boner for hating Meite. He's always been a player who needs a consistent run of about 5 games to get going.sandman wrote:No he's not.URZZZZ wrote:Meite gets an easy ride by so many people. Boye seems to be an easy victim so far. Boye is miles better than Meitesandman wrote:
Couple of well taken goals against Cardiff and that's it. If a player like Meite had missed some of the chances Puscas has in the last few games he'd have been criticised non stop by many.
People recognise Meite has limitations. You just have such a hard on for hating him that you think that people who have a more realistic and not as extreme view as yours of his weaknesses give him an easy ride.
by Snowflake Royal » 14 Sep 2019 22:11
14 Sep 2019 22:11by URZZZZ » 14 Sep 2019 23:10
14 Sep 2019 23:10Agree with the sentiment but if you scroll back to our top scorers from the last few years:Snowflake Royal wrote:Yeah that's nonsense from Urz who has a real boner for hating Meite. He's always been a player who needs a consistent run of about 5 games to get going.sandman wrote:No he's not.URZZZZ wrote:
Meite gets an easy ride by so many people. Boye seems to be an easy victim so far. Boye is miles better than Meite
People recognise Meite has limitations. You just have such a hard on for hating him that you think that people who have a more realistic and not as extreme view as yours of his weaknesses give him an easy ride.
I haven't seen a lot of Boye, but what I have seen he consistently falls over the ball and gives it away cheaply. Not writing him off but to compare him as better than last season's top scorer is lunacy.
by Snowflake Royal » 15 Sep 2019 07:35
15 Sep 2019 07:35Yeah, but you criticised him when he was scoring last season too. And you're criticising him again on his first game back in the team. Not only that but you're saying Boye, who hasn't scored at all and spends most his time ruining attacks is better. It's bullshit.URZZZZ wrote:Agree with the sentiment but if you scroll back to our top scorers from the last few years:Snowflake Royal wrote:Yeah that's nonsense from Urz who has a real boner for hating Meite. He's always been a player who needs a consistent run of about 5 games to get going.sandman wrote:
No he's not.
People recognise Meite has limitations. You just have such a hard on for hating him that you think that people who have a more realistic and not as extreme view as yours of his weaknesses give him an easy ride.
I haven't seen a lot of Boye, but what I have seen he consistently falls over the ball and gives it away cheaply. Not writing him off but to compare him as better than last season's top scorer is lunacy.
17/18 - Barrow, was poor last year
16/17 - Kermorgant, was poor the season after
15/16 - Blackman, was shocking apart from a purple patch of 6-7 games
14-15 - Cox + Murray, both criticised throughout, Cox in particular
Being top scorer one season doesn’t make you immune to criticism the season after. It may give you “x” degrees of leeway but I often talk about players working on their weaknesses and improving
Take Swift. Last year I slated him a lot for drifting out of games and being ineffective. This year he’s been nothing short of superb, and he’s worked on his weaknesses and really improved as a player, huge credit there.
Compared to Meite, where im not seeing any improvement on his weaknesses and it looks like he’s regressing as a player. Yeah, he probably does need a run of games, but with the options we have upfront that’s unlikely. Maybe saying Boye is miles better is a stupid comment and was me overreacting but I do think certain players get it easy, certainly compared to others and that does include Meite
Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot], Bing [Bot], Orion1871 and 151 guests