All matches
Championship · 2016/2017
Reading 2-0 Nottm Forest
Home

Match Report

Reading
G McCleary (10) C Gunter (62)
Nottm Forest
No goals
As so often happens in football, two former Forest players produced the goals which extended their recent poor run of results. Reading will be delighted with a win and a clean sheet which has lifted them in to fifth spot although Jaap Stam was quick to put the situation into perspective with his post-match analysis. In a fine example of hitting the nail on the head he reflected "... We also gave away possession far too easily, our first touch was not good enough and our passing was not accurate enough..." Quite clearly Stam does not want to raise expectations too high too soon in spite of a second successive victory. Although the Royals won comfortably in the end, it was a far from convincing performance and only achieved courtesy of some excellent goalkeeping from Al Habsi and some inept finishing from the visitors.

Reading made a good start in spite of some sloppy passing in the opening exchanges. Swift picked up a ball outside the box and lashed a great dipping strike which Stojkovic did well to block, but he stood no chance with McCleary’s finish from the rebound which was struck sweetly into the corner past the grounded ‘keeper. Instead of capitalising on the advantage Reading looked strangely lethargic and were let off when Kasami headed tamely at Al Habsi with the goal at his mercy. As always Reading enjoyed a plot of possession without working the goalkeeper. The game was punctuated with a succession of petty fouls. Moore was unlucky to receive a yellow due mainly to the unwarranted loud squeal from Kasami on contact. Lansbury had far too much to say for himself and seemed intent on winding everyone up. Chances came as the half progressed. A Kermogant volley was headed away and Williams hit a shot which was well saved one-handed by Stojkovic. Al Habsi made a string of saves notably one from Lichaj at full stretch. The Reading ‘keeper deserves credit for preserving Reading’s lead but he could have relieved the pressure a little if he had elected to catch some of the high balls instead of flapping at them.

Lansbury finally received the yellow card he deserved and then succeeded in provoking Van den Berg into joining him in the book. Stam wasted no time in replacing him with Evans thereby removing the risk of a red card although Lansbury can count himself lucky to stay on the pitch for his reaction when Van den Berg grabbed him. Stam denied this was the reason for the change. Either way Evans came on and did a very good job all round in his place. The game hung in the balance as Forest increasingly denied Reading time and space on the ball in their own half forcing more long balls from the back four. The second and crucial goal was well timed and came from the most unlikely source. I would certainly not advocate Gunter getting into the opponents box but I was proved wrong as the Welsh full back produced a finish of the highest quality which leaves me wondering why everyone else seems to find it so difficult. There was a slightly anxious moment when referee Davies hastily awarded a penalty when the ever irritating Lansbury took a tumble just outside the box. Thankfully Davies redeemed himself by keeping calm and after consulting his assistant correctly awarded a free kick just outside the box which came to nothing.

The two goal cushion was clearly going to be sufficient to see Reading claim their second successive victory and consolidate their position in the top half of the league. Forest were missing several players through injury and suspension but their fans were generally disgruntled and expect better things. At one point they were even fighting amongst themselves. Reading continue to plod forward without producing the sort of display which hints at promotion but they are certainly in better shape than many teams in this league at the moment. I am encouraged by the way Jaap Stam continues to maintain his high expectations of the way his team plays and is committed to ensuring his players learn and develop. Given time I believe he will succeed. A bit of extra cash might come in handy too!  
John Wells  

League Position — 2016/2017

Post-Match Fans' Opinion

  • 3P 3points 29 Oct 2016 · 10:25pm

    Well another three points. Comfortable without being convincing in any way. Forest probably should have scored but always looked like they could concede as well, even against our toothless forward line. Forest were another team visiting the Mad Stad this season that have looked pretty poor imo. AAH 8 another good performance. Is a great shot stopper (as he has been throughout his career) and was better at dealing with crosses today Gunter 6 - would have been a 5 except for the goal. My dad (who attends about one game a year) said "is that Chris Gunter who plays for Wales? He hasn't done anything but pass it backwards". Two minutes…

  • VP Vicky Pollard 30 Oct 2016 · 12:42am

    Bit of a weird one. We weren't great but somehow saw through a comfortable win. Have to be grateful for Al Habsi's wonder save at the end of the first half, game could have been a real struggle in the second half had that continued its journey to the top corner. Swift oozes class, remembered a lovely swivel and pass out wide left in the second half to push us onto the attack- he does the simple stuff well and has great awareness on the ball. Beerens was pretty anonymous. He has great skill but can disappear for long periods. Joey is a legend but today's booking was a bit unnecessary. Did a great job of winding up their number 10 to…

  • MA marlowuk 30 Oct 2016 · 1:58am

    I think this was the poorest Reading display I have seen this season. Thankfully Stam agrees and his comments of the OS are exactly right - poor first touches, passes going astray, losing possession of the ball too easily, etc. Luckily Forest were worse than us, particularly in the first half, but not by much! They played hoof-ball throughout and it is a testament to how poor we were that they would have got at least a point out of the game if it weren't for their wayward shooting and the agility and ability of (MOM) AAH. On the positive side I think we are slowly improving in the sense of playing a more positive passing game.…

  • SU Steve_Upper_West 30 Oct 2016 · 8:19am

    There is a great moment in Gladiator where Russell Crowe chops off a few heads and then shouts to the crowd "Are you not entertained" before throwing down his sword to show his general distaste for what he is being asked to do - it crossed my mind yesterday that perhaps Joey was trying to do the same thing. Maybe he was after another red card, then he could have pulled off his shirt (Andre style) flung it down and uttered those same immortal words before storming off - AND I could have stood up and shouted back "NO, I am not being entertained" :o (Anyway another 3 points - we move on) On a different note what was the minutes…

  • JC Jack Celliers 30 Oct 2016 · 8:45am

    AAH 9 Awesome in the first half. Some of the saves were fantastic, Gunter 8 Pretty faultless defensively and linked well in attack so the goal wasn't much of a surprise McShane 7 - good Moore 7 - very polished throughout but there were a few too many Forest chances Blackett 7 - a good player, but not as good as Obita when going forward VDB 6 - it was a shame that Stam had to sub him Williams 8 - in the form of his life and again was at the heart of everything Swift 7 - 5/5 for the right foot but 2/5 for the left Beerens 6 - doesn't get the service Gunter provides on the other flank, but he is OK McCleary 8 - back to his…

  • HA harry 30 Oct 2016 · 10:04am

    Mills - I hope he realises we love him really Always great to have a pantomime villain in opposition colours. Loved the 1-0/2-0 & it's Millsy's fault He waved to the East Stand after the game

  • SU Sutekh 30 Oct 2016 · 10:25am

    Another poor performance but got lucky as Forest couldn't find the net despite several excellent opportunities a blinder from Habsi. Apparently that was our first win by 2 goals or more in the league since early October last year (Middlesbrough) :shock: Just really waiting for the corner to be turned as if we start turning out good performances we'll be surprising a lot in this league. All it's going to take is practice and knowing when to hit forward passes as opposed to piddling about in front of the opposition or getting generally sloppy like it was a bad case of yesterday. Habsi MotM. Millsy was a superb pantomime villain who…

  • BO bobby1413 30 Oct 2016 · 10:33am

    Funny how people saying the performance wasn't that good but we got the win... in contrast I thought we looked great. At no point did I think Forest would score, they are the worst team I've seen this season in fact. If we strengthen in January then I think we are nailed on for a playoff finish

Read all the discussion

This Championship game took place 3535 days ago in the 2016/2017 season.