All matches
Championship · 2015/2016
Reading 0-2 Birmingham
Home

Match Report

Reading
No goals
Birmingham
C Donaldson (2) R Shotton (27)
The optimism generated by Reading’s two recent victories and a highly entertaining win earlier in the week vanished this afternoon as Reading stumbled to defeat against City side still flirting with the notion of reaching the play-offs. Falling behind in the second minute to a well taken goal from Donaldson, the Royals were unable to raise their game, conceded a second after twenty-seven minutes and never recovered. As the rain lashed down Reading struggled to find any rhythm as passes went astray, tackles were missed, and shots flew wide of the target. It was overall one of the poorer performances of the season.

Brian McDermott opted for the same starting eleven used against Forest on Tuesday although the squad was strengthened by the availability of McCleary and Rakkels. City had done their homework and did not allow Obita and Gunter time and space to get crosses in from wise positions. Neither player possess the skill or acceleration to go past players so Reading were forced to try to play their way through the centre of City’s defence which never looked likely at any stage. Cox, Kermorgant and Piazon dropped off the defence to receive the ball but City were happy for them to do so as long as they continued to pass backwards and sideways.

Obita allowed Cotterill sufficient space and time to whip in a cross to the near post in the second minute for an unmarked Donaldson to head in powerfully from close range. Reading had started slowly and the goal did not exactly galvanise them into putting City under pressure. City’s second goal came from a Cotterill free kick. Reading were outnumbered at the far post and when Al Habsi saved Shotton following up was able to prod home unchallenged. In a half littered with basic errors Reading’s attacks were ponderous and predictable. Gunter did not seem to know when to go forward or when to hold his run and was reprimanded by Quinn for his shortcomings at length and rightly so.

Lafferty and Donaldson gave McShane and Cooper problems with their physical presence up front and City had a greater appetite for winning the ball all over the pitch. Piazon missed a good chance when hoofed the ball over from close range, Quinn headed wide and Cox made room for a shot on the edge of the box but ballooned the ball into the stand. Legdzins in the city goal had little to do except collect high balls pumped into the box which he managed with ease.

Piazon was removed at half time to allow Vydra to come on to inject a bit of urgency around the City penalty area but that didn’t make much difference and dropping Cox into midfield was equally ineffective. John came on and again was unable to make the impact he usually has when Reading are chasing a game. Reading had a lot of possession in the second half but City were not troubled by the ball being passed across the pitch in front of their defence. Cooper and Kermorgant had a sight of goal but their headers were mistimed and never really troubled Legdzins. It was in the end a comfortable win for City leaving Brian McDermott with a lot to think about. The current squad do not look likely candidates for a top six finish next season. It is, I hope, going to be a busy summer in the transfer market.
John Wells

League Position — 2015/2016

Post-Match Fans' Opinion

  • WR windermere_royal 9 Apr 2016 · 5:39pm

    Shocking doesn`t do it justice. clueless trash. 71% possession but created absolutely nothing

  • RW royalp-we 9 Apr 2016 · 6:00pm

    Absolutely gutted for those paying for a day ticket today. I've come to accept I wasn't getting any more value for my money this year. The players should hang their heads in shame. But they won't. Expecting much of the same till May. Fwiw my player ratings: Al Habsi 5: little to do but that free kick palm to their player was shocking, should have got much more on it Gunter 5: some good runs down the RW in the first half but should have marked their player for the palmed free kick Obita 7: IMO the only player to take any credit today McShane 6: didn't do much wrong but stood off too much Cooper 6: See McShane Norwood 5: love him but…

  • BL blueroyals 9 Apr 2016 · 6:01pm

    4s for the players 1 for the manager

  • JM John Madejski's Wallet 9 Apr 2016 · 6:01pm

    Well that was f'cking painful Birmingham nicked 2 goals and didn't even try to score beyond that. We were just clueless against them. Fair play to them, they'd done their homework..... harry us into always passing sideways/backwards, and sit back knowing we can't cross for sh*t (Gunter and Obita just woeful) and we have no plan B Hard to single someone out, but Norwood just sat too deep, underhit passes and slowed everything down. But just how bad was Williams?! Constantly running in to trouble and pushed off the ball like child. Inept in every way

  • 7B 72 bus 9 Apr 2016 · 6:07pm

    I have had a season ticket for the last 15 seasons, today was my last game. Simply can't bring myself to sit through the remaining home games, next season after a summer off I may think differently but this squad is simply not worth paying to watch.

  • GE genome 9 Apr 2016 · 6:11pm

    Anyone else spot the helmet in Y25 sporting a Reading shirt with "Yaya Toure" on the back? I despair, sometimes I really do.

  • RO Royalwaster 9 Apr 2016 · 6:14pm

    Don't think you can blame the players today. All the managers fault. No width, no strategy. Clueless.

  • SU Sutekh 9 Apr 2016 · 6:17pm

    Utter ******* shambles That is all.

Read all the discussion

This Championship game took place 3734 days ago in the 2015/2016 season.